I never said that every rich person is an idiot and every unsuccessful person unlucky, only that in the absence of much additional information it is preferable to reserve one’s judgment. It is safer. Nassim N. Taleb
Financial literacy programs: more savings, not better investing?
Page 1 of 6
Financial education (called financial literacy programs) seems to be the flavor of the day everywhere. Our own site has a strong educational component: give information to help you manage your portfolio yourself (DIY investing). As a result our own general reaction can only be one of supporting such initiatives , which in
theory should lead to increased financial literacy, and subsequently to better financial decisions, and even enable some persons to become DIY investors. But is the enthusiasm of the financial industry for such programs disinterested? Does the industry really have any incentive to promote independent investing?
What is financial education?
The OECD Council in June 2005 defined financial education as follows:
Financial education is the process by which consumers / investors
improve their financial knowledge of financial products and concepts
acquire, through information, training or advice objective, skills and confidence needed to better understand the risks and opportunities to finance
make reasoned, informed choices
know where to find advice and information
take other initiatives to improve their financial well-being Source: translation of OECD document doc.1431, p.14
Note that, as defined, these objectives are not intended to achieve real financial independence, but seem more designed to encourage (know where to find advice and information) investors to rely on financial institutions. And if the assistance sought does not prove to be informed and objective, well it’s the investor’s problem.
The movement toward financial education
In recent years there has been a widespread movement to promote financial education; in Ontario, see Fair Canada for a useful overview, and also see the following on the website of Fair Canada.
In our view financial education is necessary, not only because education and access to information in general is an essential component of any modern society, but also because it is particularly necessary in the financial sector to help people to protect themselves because of disparities in information and in economic and bargaining power i.e. to protect the weak against the strong. In this, there is little difference between trying to protect consumers and doing the same for investors.
In our view, the challenge of education in the financial sector is not only to ensure the availability of information (on the contrary, in many cases there is often an excess of information), it is also to ensure that the content of information made available to beneficiaries of the programs reflects the inequalities between the parties in the financial sector.